Asperger's kids need extra help to succeed. |
Improving
the Reading Comprehension of Asperger's Students' While Perfecting
the Study Habits of Average Kids
Evelyn
E. Smith
Ph.
D in English from Texas Christian University (1995)
M.S.
in Library Science, University of North Texas (2012)
Children
and adults coping with Asperger's Syndrome* never completely outgrow
this genetically-based learning disorder. However, direct
instruction, learning how to break the parts of a reading assignment
or a test into smaller, more easily-understandable parts, and taking
the effort to visually map a narrative can increase their reading
comprehension skills. Conversely, since autistic characteristics
exist on a continuum, average students learning how to study or
wishing to add details to their essays can benefit from learning some
of the study tips
that help Asperger's Syndrome students integrate details
into a coherent whole. Even so, individuals who struggle with
Asperger's symptoms will always have problems grasping the emotional
content of narratives because they will never stop having problems
reading social cues.
*Writers spell Asperger's with and without the apostrophe.
First some definitions are in order:
Diagnostic Criteria for 229.80
Asperger's Disorder. (2002). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
Mental Disorders (DSM-IV).
Washington, D.C.: American Psychiatric Association. Retrieved from
http://www.autreat.com/dsm4-aspergers.html
In 2013, the American Psychiatric Association classified Asperger's as a subcategory of autism, although educators and parents still use the terms like Asperger's Disorder, and Asperger's or Asperger Syndrome.
Autism Spectrum Disorder. (2013). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders(DSM-5). American Psychiatric Association: Washington, D. C. Retrieved from http://www.dsm5.org/Documents/Autism%20Spectrum%20Disorder%20Fact%20Sheet.pdf
Because
Asperger's Syndrome children and adults have displayed similar
behavioral traits to those with High Functioning Autism (HFA), some
educational psychologists group them under a single label.
___________
A Short Bibliography of Research
on Asperger's & Reading Comprehension
Most Asperger's students do better in written
work if they can use a computer.
|
Researchers confirm the long-held belief that children and adults diagnosed with Asperger's Syndrome. can easily sound out words. However, they have trouble comprehending what they have read because they focus too much on the details, failing to understand the text's main idea. AS readers also have problems predicting what will happen next, nor can they easily relate to the emotions that the characters in a fictional narrative might display. Because they interpret text literally, they often can't grasp figurative language and fail to detect sarcasm. Analyzing the parts of a text—for example, understanding how pronouns refer back to their antecedents, and mapping concepts like setting, characters, motivations, and main ideas-helps these readers synthesize a complete narrative.
Ball-Erickson,
Melissa. (2012, October 12). Effective Reading Comprehension
Strategies for Students with Autism Spectrum Disorders in the
Elementary General Education Classroom. Master's in Education.
Northern Michigan University. Retrieved from
http://www.nmu.edu/education/sites/DrupalEducation/files/UserFiles/Ball-Erickson_Melissa_MP.pdf
Ball-Erickson
reviews the effectiveness of seven strategies for teaching reading
comprehension to Autism Spectrum Disorders students in small-group
settings: Her thesis emphasizes 1) using direct instruction,
chunking information into easily-understandable parts, 2) accessing
assistive technology and Computer Assisted Instruction, 3) grouping
students in pairs, thus providing Class Wide Peer Tutoring (CWPT),
4) activating prior knowledge, 5) modeling instruction while thinking
aloud, 6) asking students to retell a story or page in a text, and
7) allowing students to use as many of their senses as possible by
using multi-sensorary graphics (2012, October 12, p. 4).
Educators
group ASD readers into three categories, according to their strengths
and weaknesses in understanding a text:
- Text Bound ASD readers* pay too much attention to small details, but they can't interpret the text's overall message.
- Strategic ASD readers can easily answer explicit and implicit details, but they have difficulty predicting what will happen next and can't relate emotionally to a narrative.
- Imaginative ASD readers rely primarily on visual cues to understand concepts and have problems understanding syntax, semantics, and the sue of prepositions.
(Ball-Erickson,
2012, October 12, p. 9)
*Ball-Erickson
uses the term “comprehenders”.
ASD
readers struggle with internalizing these meta-cognitive strategies
necessary for reading comprehension:
- Monitoring what they have read for meaning;
- Using and creating schema (for building a framework for learning);
- Asking questions (about the text as they read);
- Determining importance (grasping main ideas);
- Making inferences (applying ideas about specific instances to general categories);
- Understanding sensory and emotional imagery (discerning figures of speech and sarcasm);
- Synthesizing material (summarizing and combining different concepts.
(Ball-Erickson,
2012, October 12, p. 11)
Main-streamed
ASD students can successfully comprehend text when instruction
employs a variety of strategies:
- Direct Instruction: A fluent adult reader briefly analyzes the concept being taught, then he or she breaks it down into a series of small steps (Ball-Erickson, 2012, October 12, p. 17).
- Assistive Technology and Computer Assisted Instruction: Computer software programs prove particularly effective in providing visual cues for making inferences, distinguishing relevant information, and determining cause and effect (Ball-Erickson, 2012, October 12, p 19).
- Class Wide Peer Tutoring (CWPT): Pairing good readers with students who need help increases correct reading responses (Ball-Erickson, 2012, October 12, p. 22).
Activating
Prior Knowledge:
Telling stories based on personal experience or connect a reading
passage with a well-known TV show or movie establishes connections
that help readers make inferences. Thus, reading instruction relies
on the KWL
model of instruction:
- What the Students Knows
- What the Student Wants to Know
- What the Student Has Already Learned
(Ball-Erickson, 2012, October 12, para. 22-23)
- Thinking Aloud: As an accomplished adult reader voices his or her thoughts, he or she models meta cognitive comprehension strategies for the students (Ball-Erickson, 2012, October 12, p. p. 23-24).
- Retelling: ASD students apparently responded better when asked to retell a story rather than when they are asked specific questions about the story (Ball-Erickson, 2012, October 12, p. p. 23-24).
- Multi-sensory graphics: Manipulative teacher aids help ASD students understand complex concepts (Ball-Erickson, 2012, October 12, p. 24).
Results
and Analysis Relative to the Problem: No single strategy works all
the time for all problem readers (Ball-Erickson, 2012, October 12, p.
27).
Gately,
Susan E. (2006). Facilitating reading comprehension for students on
the autism spectrum. Instruction and Student Outcomes. Teaching
Exceptional Children, 40(3) 40-45. Retrieved from
http://www.curriculumconnection4sped.com/uploads/1/2/6/4/12648571/susan_gately_reading_comp_article.pdf
Researchers
investigating the reading comprehension of children with Asperger's
and other high-functioning autism spectrum disorders have found that
they have poorer silent reading skills than oral reading abilities.
Moreover, HFA students display “significant differences between
factual and higher order, inferential comprehension (Gately, 2006, p.
40). In other words, these readers can't infer what will happen next
or understand the emotions that the narrative's characters feel.
This is because AS and HFA readers have trouble integrating language
social understanding, and emotional intent perhaps because they focus
on the details instead of grasping a passage's main idea (Gately,
2006, p. 40). These
learning disabled readers have trouble determining what others think
and thus have difficulty detecting deception and understanding
metaphors, sarcasm, jokes, and irony (Gately, 2006, p. 41).
Accordingly,, this inability to grasp spoken language in context
leads to poor reading comprehension skills when trying to recognize
the emotions the characters are feelings and determine their
motivations (Gately, 2006, p. 41).
Strategies
for Higher Order Reading Comprehension Skills
Strategies
for improving higher order reading comprehension skills include
priming background knowledge (building on what the readers already
knows), taking picture walks, using visual maps, listening to and
participating think aloud sessions, pairing off to do some reciprocal
thinking, understanding the narrative's text structure, using
goal-structure mapping, emotional thermometers, and reading or
watching social stories to discover the characters' emotions in the
short story or novel then are reading (Gately, 2006, p. 41).
Priming
Primary Knowledge
The
more readers know about a topic the more easily they can connect with
the text, although possessing accurate knowledge about a subject is
crucial (Gately, 2006, p. 41).
Picture
Walks
Younger
readers survey illustrations accompanying a story before reading the
text, making predictions about what will happen (Gately, 2006, p.
41).
Visual
Maps
Using
visual maps or diagrams helps readers summarize a short story or
novel, determine its setting and characters as well as the order of
the action, and the problems the hero encounters (Gately, 2006, p.
42).
Think
Aloud and Reciprocal Reading
Listening
to a proficient reader read aloud while he or she occasionally pauses
to reflect on the passage, asking questions on the text, models
predicting, questioning, clarifying, and summarizing techniques
(Gately, 2006, p. 42).
In
reciprocal teaching, or paired reading, pairs of students share their
thoughts about the text as they read it aloud while looking for
specific information about what they have read For example, they
might summarizing a story, look for examples of foreshadowing in the
text, or determine a passage's main idea. This reading strategy
builds a scalfold on which the students can hand their understanding
of the text. Along the way, they can color code, or highlight,
particular aspects of the text (Gately, 2006, p. 42).
Understanding
Narrative Text Structure
Readers
begin by identifying the main characters of a story as subjects of a
sentence and then attaching an action verb and a predicate to
describe what they did. The students put the two separate parts of
the story on different story strips, for example. Harry Potter (Subject) /
received (Verb) a letter (Direct Object). Subsequently, readers can
sequence the narrative and insert transition words between the
sentence strips, thus determining how one character's actions
influenced another character's actions (Gately, 2006, p. 43).
Emotional
Thermometers
Color
coding the text with highlighting that stands for different emotions
helps AS readers understand and describe the characters' feelings and
emotions; for instance, green might stand for good ideas and happy
feelings and red might symbolize bad ideas and angry feelings
(Gately, 2006, p. 43).
Social
Stories
Social
Stories found in popular books,TV shows, and motion pictures as well
as those that come from teachers and parents personal experiences
help AS readers relate to the stories they are reading in class
(Gately, 2006, p. 44). For instance, hearing about Mom's adventures
at Girl Scout camp or watching Parent Trap might help the AS reader
who has never gone to camp relate to Rick Riordan's Percy Jackson series.
Nation,
Kate,Clarke,Paula, & Wright, Barry, et al. (2006, August 6).
Patterns of reading ability in children with autism spectrum.
Journal
of Autism Development Disorders,
36, 911-919. doi: 10.1007/s10803-006-0130-1. Retrieved from
researchgate.net
[PDF]
Researchers
assessed word recognition skills, non-word decoding, text reading
accuracy, and reading comprehension in 32 children out of a sample
size of 41 Autism Spectrum Disorder children, thus confirming the
stereotype that ASD readers suffer from impaired reading
comprehension while their word recognition skills fell within the
normal range (Nation, 2006, August 6, Abstract, p. 911). Existing
literature had already stereotyped ASD students as at risk readers
because of their poor reading comprehension, although numerous
examples existed of ASD children with “exceptional” reading
skills (Nation, 2006, August 6, p. 911). Two
processes are necessary to comprehend reading: 1) the ability to
identify words and 2) the ability to assembly words into messages.
However, these two processes can develop out-of-step with each other
(Nation, 2006,August 6, p. 911).
Reading
Accuracy and Autism
Previous
studies have shown that High-functioning Autistic readers are as
proficient at sounding-out words as their normal-developing peers,
who read at a “reasonably advanced level”, However, reading
comprehension was significantly lower in children with autism than
their controls matched for I.Q. level (Nation, 2006, August 6, p.
912). Indeed, in some instances, autistic children had
“well-developed” word recognition skills, but very impaired
levels of reading comprehension—a condition known as hyperlexia
(Nation, 2006, August 6, p. 912). Educational psychologists
theorizes that this condition may result because autistic individuals
tend to be interested in a text's details rather than its overall
meaning (Nation, 2006, August 6, p. 912).
Researchers
in this study wanted to determine the reading levels of a relatively
large population of ASD children as well as to determine their
separate word accuracy and reading comprehension level. At this
point, they theorized that children with poor reading comprehension
levels would have trouble understanding the intricacies of oral
language. They also wanted to examine the difference between
accurately decoding words and understanding completely what they
read. Additionally, they wanted to know whether the children would
be able to sound out nonsense words (Nation, 2006, August 6, p. 913).
Method/Methods
and Procedure
Recruiting
from patients at the Children and Adolescent Mental Health Clinic in
New York City, the researchers measured the reading skills of 41
autistic children between the ages of 6 and 15 with “measurable
language skills, testing them in a quiet school classroom or in their
home, using three tests to determine their reading accuracy and one
test to determine their reading comprehension levels, These
assessments took one and a half hours (Nation, 2006, August 6, p.
913).
Reading
Accuracy
Researchers
tested the children for decoding skills, word recognition, and their
ability to read interconnected text. Some questions asked for a
literal understanding of a passage, but others required the children
to make inferences (Nation, 2006, August 6, p. 914).
Oral
Language Skills
Oral
language tests required the children to understand spoken language
without looking at any pictures and to use their knowledge of the
world to determine the meaning of the words (Nation, 2006, August 6,
p 914).
Nonverbal
Ability
A
test that required the children to sound-out nonsense words assessed
their non-verbal abilities (Nation, 2006, August 6, p. 914).
Results
Since
9 of the 41 children recruited for the research were completely
unable to read, they were excluded from further analysis. However,
of the 32 remaining children, all tests dealing with reading
accuracy—word reading, text reading, and non-word reading—all
fell within the normal range, but reading comprehension scores fell
below population norms (Nation, 2006, August 6, 914).
Component
Reading Skills
Testing
showed that reading skills are interconnected at “a statistically
significant level” but the correlations were “fairly modest” in
size (Nation, 2006, August 6, p. 914).
Deficits
in Reading Comprehension
Of
the 32 children with measurable reading skills, 65 percent of the
sample, 65 percent scored at least one statistical deviation below
population norms while 38 percent scored two standard deviations
below population norms. However, 20 percent of this sample achieved
word reading levels in the normal range, and ten of the these had
reading reading comprehension levels in the normal range or above
(Nation, 2006, August 6, p. 915).
O'Connor,
Irene & Klein, Perry D. (2004, April). Exploration of strategies
for facilitating the reading comprehension of high-functioning
students with autism spectrum disorders. Journal of Autism and
Development Disorders, 34(2) 115-127. Retrieved from
http://w.aspires-relationships.com/exploration_of_strategies_for_facilitating_the_reading_comprehension_of_hf_students_with_asd.pdf
Educators
have finally grasped the necessity that it's important for students
diagnosed with high-functioning-autism to read well. However,
successfully teaching this clientele requires instructors to employ
reading interventions since while these readers easily recognize
individual words, they don't necessarily comprehend what they read
(O'Connor, 2004, April, p. 115). As for decoding skills, HFA readers
display abilities that are adequate, but can be equal to or above
average their chronological age norms (O'Connor, 2004, April, p.
116).
Most
HFA readers understand varying degrees of syntax, but their
grammatical ability is delayed when compared to other students since
without additional help, they have trouble referring back pronouns to
their antecedents. They also find it difficult to use prior
knowledge to support their reading comprehension (O'Connor, 2004,
April, p. 117). Thus, O' Connor and Klein hypothesize that relying
on prior knowledge to understand a narrative and integrating a text
that extends beyond the level of a clause might be related (O'Connor,
2004, April, p. 117).
When
O'Connor and Klein tested 24 males and one female diagnosed as
high-functioning autistic readers who displayed who were excellent
decoded, but had low reading comprehension skills, they found that
anaphoric cuing, or teaching students how pronouns refer back to
certain antecedents, improved their reading comprehension scores more
than the use of pre-reading questions and cloze questions did.
See
these Online tutorials:
14.2
Pronouns: Identifying
pronouns and Antecedents. (n. d.). Grade Seven/Bronze Online exercise
bank. Pearson: Prentice
Hall Writing & Grammar Online Exercise Bank.
Retrieved from
http://www.phschool.com/atschool/writing_grammar_08/grade7/exercise_bank/chapter14/wag7_act_14-2a.cfm
Noun/pronoun
antecedent agreement—exercise 1 & 2. (n. d.). OWL Learning
Center at D'Youville College. Retrieved from
http://depts.dyc.edu/learningcenter/owl/exercises/agreement_pa_ex1.htm
Simmons,
Robin L. (2015). Pronoun Agreement Exercise. Retrieved from
http://chompchomp.com/hotpotatoes/proagree01.htm
___________
These
videos also might help explain pronoun-antecedent agreement:
Antecedent
Video Song official--(Mrs. Dales Grammar Jingles). (2011, March 3).
Florence City Schools. Retrieved from
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YKmGblTbgu4
Ensure
pronoun-antecedent agreement—Lesson 3 of 4 (Common Core Standard L.
3 1F). (2012, October 23). Learn Zillow. Retrieved from
https://search.yahoo.com/search;_ylt=A0LEVxSO5aFUZeEAIc5XNyoA?ei=UTF-8&type=B001US400D20140827&fr=mcsaoffblock&rs=0&p=pronouns+and+antecedents+exercises+for+kids&rs=0&fr2=rs-bottom
Pronouns
and Antecedents 3CNC. (2012, November 7). Retrieved from
https://search.yahoo.com/search?fr=mcafee&type=B011US400D20140827&p=pronouns+and+antecedent+videos
Similarly,
AS students might also benefit from sentence combining exercises:
Combining
sentences through subordination. (n. d.). Owlet.letu.edu.
Retrieved from
http://owlet.letu.edu/grammarlinks/sentence/sentence3d3.html
Sentence
structure: Combining and subordinating. (n. d.). St. Lawrence
University: The
Word Studio.
____________
Graphic novels interest poor readers in reading! |
Popular
Tips for Teaching Reading Comprehension to Asperger Students
Popular
tips for teaching reading comprehension to Asperger students echo the
findings of researchers, who caution that only a small percentage of
Asperger's students reading comprehension levels match the scores of
their peers. These strategies, however, help Asperger's students
compete in mainstream classrooms just as they might polish the study
habits, test-taking, and essay-writing skills of average students.
Benson,
Shawna. (2010, March 8). How to teach reading to individuals with
Asperger Syndrome. Education.com.
Retrieved from
http://www.education.com/reference/article/teach-reading-individual-asperger-ASD/
The
Dignostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders,
4th
edition, notes that Asperger Syndrome individuals have problems
dealing with social interaction—interacting with peers,
interpreting non-verbal social cues, sharing different
points-of-view, reciprocity give and take, understanding how parts of
a narrative, process, or report fits into the whole, and managing
executive functioning. Hence, they often rely on routines and
rituals that often clash with contemporary instructional strategies
(Benson, 2010, March 8, para. 3). Learners with AS behavioral
patterns might appear to absorb automatically certain skills and
information, but they need formal instruction on how to decode
reading patterns, thus often necessitating remedial phonics
instruction (Benson, 2010, March 8, para. 4).
Benson also furnished a chart that substitutes learning strategies specifically geared to help AS students:
- Organizing a readers' theater, encouraging AS and High Functioning Autism students as well as their classmates to act out a novel, short story, or play's dialogue.
- Role-playing a situation or narrative;
- Formally teaching facial expressions to Asperger's students;
- Assigning partners and roles to group members before assigning group work;
- Providing a syllabus of topics to be studied to high school, middle school, and elementary school students, so students (and their parents) can plan ahead;
- Furnishing written time frames for tasks to be accomplished each class period;
- Allowing AS students extra time to accomplish certain tasks (perhaps outside of class);
- Using visual and audio reminders to signal that the class is changing activities;
- Providing AS students with folders in which to place unfinished work;
- Warning AS students ahead of time that they might be called upon;
- Placing parts of a narrative or report in a visual structure that represents the whole assignment;
- Breaking assignments into incremental, easily understood steps;
- Giving directions in writing and highlighting text on handouts;
- Using paired reading and writing partners to offer each other immediate feedback;
- Providing graphic organizer handouts like Freytag's Pyramid, which serves as a flow chart to help readers understand narratives: http://www.ereadingworksheets.com/readingworksheets/story-pyramid-graphic-organizer.html
(Benson,
2010, March 8, para. 5)
Recommendations and Conclusion: A balance between the various types of instruction helps ASD students improve their reading comprehension skills (Ball-Erickson, 2012, October 12, p. 28).
Dominica, Sharon. (2014, October 28). Does your student with Asperger's understand what he reads. Bright Hub Education. Retrieved from http://www.brighthubeducation.com/parents-and-special-ed/96806-reading-to-children-with-aspergers/
The following techniques may increase the reading comprehension of the Asperger's student:
AS college and university students may [still] exhibit language peculiarities, self-impose rigid rules and routines, have problems reading non-verbal cues, be clumsy, have problems making friends, and obsess over overwhelming interests (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 5).
Teachers dictate their class's style of communication, indicating accepted levels of behavior as well as the students' responses and attitudes, so if an instructor's sarcasm or ridicule indicates that poking fun at someone is okay, it becomes “open season”. Conversely, a professor's patient and understanding behavior can set the classroom norm (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 10-12).
This very personal decision should be left up to individual students to make after careful thought (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 13).
What problems may occur within the teaching setting?
Group Work
AS students may find group work stressful, for they have problems empathizing with others. Certain members of the group or a staff member may therefore need to step in and act as mediators to ensure that the AS student understands what others in a group expect of him or her (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 14).
Lack of Comprehension
Figurative language may confuse AS students, who simultaneously feel embarrassed and reluctant to admit that they don't understand a remark. AS individuals often use coping mechanisms, like humor, to cover up this problem. The instructor [or another student acting as a mentor] at this point can step in to interpret what another person has said (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 15).
Lack of Empathy
Educational psychologists refer to the AS individuals' inability to show empathy as a lack of “Theory of Mind” (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 16). When they show a disregard for others' feelings, an instructor or colleague therefore needs to quietly and sincerely tell them what effect their words or actions have had, or else they might not make this connection on their own (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 16). Also, because AS individuals have trouble interpreting nonverbal parts of a conversation as well as understanding the facial expressions that often accompany sarcasm, the difference between what they know and what they think their audience knows may also result in bruised feelings and misunderstandings (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 17—18).
Problem with Motivation
Most students apply themselves to learning a course's entire curriculum, including parts of it they don't like, but AS students may focus only on what they enjoy doing, sabotaging their own changes of success (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 10).
Distress Caused by Lack of Information
Detailed information reassures autism spectrum individuals (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 20).
Social Chameleons
AS individuals are good at blending in when they participate in familiar situations with predictable events; but when things go wrong, they reveal themselves as individuals coping with High-Functioning Autism (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 21).
A Final Caveat
No two individuals with Asperger's or Autism act in the same manner (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 22).
Roome, Deborah. (2011). Asperger's occupations: Embarking on a successful career. Healthguideinfo.com. Retrieved from http://www.healthguideinfo.com/aspergers-syndrome/p110668/
Recommendations and Conclusion: A balance between the various types of instruction helps ASD students improve their reading comprehension skills (Ball-Erickson, 2012, October 12, p. 28).
Dominica, Sharon. (2014, October 28). Does your student with Asperger's understand what he reads. Bright Hub Education. Retrieved from http://www.brighthubeducation.com/parents-and-special-ed/96806-reading-to-children-with-aspergers/
The following techniques may increase the reading comprehension of the Asperger's student:
Teaching Words with Pictures
Try to associate words with pictures (Dominica, 2014, October 28, para. 3).
Practical Experiences Not Fantasy
Because Asperger's students have trouble grasping fantasy, they best understand practical and non-fiction topics (Dominica, 2014, October 28, para. 4). In other words, a parent or teacher needs to be on hand to ask probing questions to ensure that they have understood what they have read when confronted with some types of fiction.
Sentences & Stories with Pictures
When using pictures, make sure that they aren't too abstract (Dominica, 2014, October 28, para. 5).
Use of Social Stories & Comic Strip Conversions
Stories with realistic illustrations as well as those told with comic strip illustrations help Asperger's readers connect with the text (Dominica, 2014, October 28, para. 6). Hint: Try interesting upper elementary and middle school Asperger's readers in graphic novels.
To Teach Where, When, Why & What
Furnish short explanatory questions and answer paragraphs to help explain the text (Dominica, 2014, October 28, para. 7). Note: Verbally, briefly quiz the Asperger's reader to determine if he or she understand the main idea or else make use of bullet outlines to summarize what he or she needs to remember.
Limit Text Per Page
Limit the amount of text the Asperger's reader sees on a single page (Dominica, 2014, October 28, para. 8). If possible, allow the student to read the text Online or cover part of the text, allowing him or her to limit the amount of text he or she sees at a time.
Hutten, Mark. (n. d.). Asperger's
students and poor reading comprehension. My Aspergers Child.
Retrieved from http://www.myaspergerschild.com/2010/12/aspergers-students-and-poor-reading.html
Since children diagnosed with
Asperger's Syndrome are visual thinkers, they struggle with some of
the aspects of reading comprehension, finding it difficult to
understand figurative language (Hutten, n. d., para. 2).
Consequently, parents and teachers need to take the following
affirmative action:
- Focus on helping AS students understand the story's abstract words and concepts.
- When possible, limit sentences on a page (possibly enlarging the text Online or else copying the Online text to a separate page.
- Select stories that illustrate everyday activities.
- When possible, use stories with illustrations (or else search Online for applicable illustrations or ask AS readers to illustrate what they have read).
(Hutten, n. d.,
para. 3-8)
Kluth, Paula. (2010). Tell me about
the story: Comprehension strategies for students with autism. Reading
Rockets. Retrieved from
http://www.readingrockets.org/article/tell-me-about-story-comprehension-strategies-students-autism
Many students with autism lack the
communication skills “to tell about the story”. These readers
may understand what they have read, but since they can't express what
they know, they struggle to answer questions (Kluth, 2010, para.
2-3).
If a teacher doesn't know whether
autism students have understood a passage, he or she can employ
numerous strategies to allow them to demonstrate their knowledge:
- Autism [and Asperger's] students need plenty of wait time to respond;
- A teacher might ask the question verbally while also putting it in written form;
- He or she might allow AS students to write out their answers, or circle the correct multiple-choice answer.
- Some students respond best if the teacher asks the question in a different accent or uses a prop in the lesson.
(Kluth, 2010,
para. 4)
If autism students are completely
unable to answer questions, teachers might ask them to draw pictures,
point to the correct answers, sign or pantomime an answer, make a
diorama, or create a collage or painting to illustrate their
knowledge of a narrative (Kluth, 2010, para. 5). However, even if
these options are unable to elicit a recognizable response to a
reading passage, teachers might determine whether students exhibit a
response by a change in behavior (Kluth, 2010, para. 6).
Most autism students, however, need
direct instructional support in making predictions, visualizing
events, identifying the author's purpose, and separating a text's
main ideas from the details (Kluth, 2010, para. 7). Thus, the
following comprehension strategies may improve the comprehension
skills of autism students:
Build Background Knowledge
Build Background Knowledge
- Help AS students create [emotional and personal] connections with what they have read:
- Brainstorm, writing down ideas that summarize the text;
- Share personal experiences helping AS readers connect with a topic
- Ask questions about the topic: Make connections between the topic and the students' own experiences, using movies and books related to the text.
- Mainstreaming Aspergers' and High-Functioning Autism students builds background knowledge.
(Kluth, 2010,
para. 13-14)
Think Aloud
Teachers in a whole class format might think aloud while reading a text to a class, thus modeling reading comprehension strategies, asking questions, explaining inferences, determining the importance of different parts of the text, and connecting the text with all the students' background knowledge. Meanwhile students follow along while the teacher reads the text, Teachers can also write down their thoughts as they verbalize them (Kluth, 2010, para. 15-17). Of course, these thinking aloud strategies also work with individual students in tutorial sessions.
Drama
Teachers can also have students act out parts of a narrative. While elementary teachers are most likely to use this reading comprehension strategy, middle school and high school teachers have also used it effectively. Different types of drama, such as dramatic readings or full-story performances, work best for different genres (Kluth, 2010, para. 18-20). Note: AS students might also benefit from attending live performances or participating in Little Theater productions.
Reciprocal Teaching
Students help each other understand what they have read as pairs of students summarize, ask each other questions, clarify the passage and predict what will happen as they take turns assuming the teacher's role (Kluth, 2010, para. 21). Once students with autism are comfortable performing the teacher's role, the teacher shifts from directly instructing the class to monitoring everyone's progress and giving feedback. Students with [high-functioning] autism, however, may need this teaching strategy modeled more than once (Kluth, 2010, para. 22-23).
Teachers in a whole class format might think aloud while reading a text to a class, thus modeling reading comprehension strategies, asking questions, explaining inferences, determining the importance of different parts of the text, and connecting the text with all the students' background knowledge. Meanwhile students follow along while the teacher reads the text, Teachers can also write down their thoughts as they verbalize them (Kluth, 2010, para. 15-17). Of course, these thinking aloud strategies also work with individual students in tutorial sessions.
Drama
Teachers can also have students act out parts of a narrative. While elementary teachers are most likely to use this reading comprehension strategy, middle school and high school teachers have also used it effectively. Different types of drama, such as dramatic readings or full-story performances, work best for different genres (Kluth, 2010, para. 18-20). Note: AS students might also benefit from attending live performances or participating in Little Theater productions.
Reciprocal Teaching
Students help each other understand what they have read as pairs of students summarize, ask each other questions, clarify the passage and predict what will happen as they take turns assuming the teacher's role (Kluth, 2010, para. 21). Once students with autism are comfortable performing the teacher's role, the teacher shifts from directly instructing the class to monitoring everyone's progress and giving feedback. Students with [high-functioning] autism, however, may need this teaching strategy modeled more than once (Kluth, 2010, para. 22-23).
Retelling
Since some students are
uncomfortable responding to question/answer formats, they may best
evidence their reading comprehension by retelling a story in their
own words after they have read it silently or listened and followed
along while a teacher read it aloud. While the students are doing
this, they might also draw pictures or take notes that will help them
retell the story aloud. The teacher first models this strategy or
else has students model retelling a text. The teacher might also ask
students to look for main ideas and specific details when retelling
the story. Students can draw while retelling a text, use photos or
clip art to illustrate the retelling, or else use a graphic map or
organizer to aid in the retelling. Students may also work in pairs
or small groups (Kluth, 2010, para. 24-25).
Mitchell, Sharon. (n.
d.). Weak reading comprehension.
Reading Comprehension. Autism Help Home.
Retrieved from
http://www.autismsite.ca/html/reading_comprehension.html
Mitchell furnishes some great ideas
on helping learning-disabled readers become master readers even if
many of the links she has furnished no longer work. Thus, this Web
page has substituted similar links:
While teachers and parents need to
build on AS students' current strengths, they must also ensure that
struggling readers understands what they have read, for students who
stumble over decoding a passage, often loose its meaning (Mitchell,
n. d., para. 2-3). Tutorials, for example, might have AS students
read aloud while an instructor points out the meaning of commas,
periods, and questions (Mitchell, n. d., para. 4).
Teachers and parents also need to
determine whether or not struggling readers can pick out patterns in
a story or report, analyze, synthesize, and predict complex ideas.
In other words, what learning skills in Bloom's Taxonomy has
he or she mastered? (Mitchell, n. d., para. 5). Of course, it's
crucial for all students to master the lower levels skills before
moving on to the higher ones.
See:
Garland, Stacia. (2011, May 3).
Bloom's Taxonomy: Critical thinking skills for kids. Exquisite
Minds. Retrieved from
http://www.exquisite-minds.com/idea-of-the-week/blooms-taxonomy-critical-thinking-skills/
It's also important to determine how
each struggling reader deals with figurative language, rhyme, and
meter (Mitchell, n. d., para. 6). Videos play out in the minds of
most “good readers” while they are reading a work of fiction or
listening to a figurative poem, but those students diagnosed with
autism spectrum disorders do best when the text also furnishes
outside visual cues.
See:
- VISUALIZING & VERBALIZING for Language Comprehension & Thinking. (n. d.). Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes. Retrieved from http://www.lindamoodbell.com/programs/visualizing-verbalizing.htmlThis subscription program uses graphics and retelling techniques to emphasize important reading comprehension concepts (Mitchell, n. d., para. 6)
Even Asperger's students who appear
“highly verbal” often have weak language processing skills so
regularly incorporating drawing assignments and concept maps in their
lesson plans helps them grasp otherwise difficult concepts (Mitchell,
n. d., para. 7). Visual reminders also help students write detailed,
on topic essays.
See:
- Bartlett, Krista. (n. d.). Five paragraph essay template. Ms B's Radical Website. Retrieved from http://kristabartlett.weebly.com/uploads/3/9/0/8/3908568/essaytemplate.pdfThis is similar to the box outlin that this writer used as a middle school Writing Across the Curriculum teacher 25 years ago as well as when she taught remedial rhetoric and composition at the college level during the 1990s.
- Bubbl.us. (2014). LKCollab, LLC. Retrieved from https://bubbl.us/Try out this Website with five free trials. After that, a subscription might prove helpful for older students.
- Concept maps. (2014). Reading Rockets. WETA Public Broadcasting. Retrieved from http://www.readingrockets.org/strategies/concept_mapsReading Rockets offers some easily understandable concept maps.
Using a story grammar approach, the
Asperger's students might group the aspects of a story by setting,
characters, problem (or main idea), and what will happen next (or
foreshadowing) (Mitchell, n. d., para. 10).
A quick survey of Mitchell's concept
mapping software programs found two free-trial software programs that
also allow users to organize ideas visually and look like they are
comparably easy to use:
- Kidspiration. (2014). Inspiration Software, Inc. Retrieved from http://www.inspiration.com/Kidspiration
- By far the easiest concept mapping tool to use, Kidspiration claims to strengthen reading and writing skills and to build understanding of math concepts.
- Smart Draw. (2014). SmartDraw, LLC. Retrieved from http://www.smartdraw.com/specials/ppc/smartdraw.htm?id=104867
- High school and college students might appreciate using this visual tool.
(Mitchell, n.
d., para. 11)
While thinking about thinking, or
meta-cognition, comes naturally to many good readers, this reflection
doesn't come all that easily for kids with Asperger's, ADHD, and
other neurological disorders, so this checklist might help guide them
through their reading assignments:
See also:
Thompson. (n. d.). Metacognitive
Checklist. GDHS English. Retrieved from
http://www.gdhsenglish.com/thompson/assets/pdfs/ENG3U1%20pdf%27s/Frankenstein/Metacognitive_Checklist.pdf
(Mitchell, n. d., para. 12)
Although college freshman
composition students are the intended audience of this checklist,
parents and teachers might simplify this list so that it fits the
needs of elementary and middle school students, perhaps asking
questions from one section of the list at a time.
____________
Asperger's individuals are visual thinkers. |
Understanding
Asperger's Kids' Thinking & Behavior: Some Problems & Some Solutions
Effectively teaching reading
comprehension to Asperger's Syndrome students also requires teachers
and parents to understand how Asperger's students think and why they
behave the way they do. While high-functioning autistic students may
in time became highly successful in fields that pay lots of attention
to detail, they must always deal with a learning disability that
hampers their ability to intuit social cues and fail to focus on the
big picture.
Prigg, Mark. (2015, January 2).
Are Pets the key to treating autism? Researchers say children with
ets have far better social skills. Daily Mail. Retrieved from
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2895069/Are-PETS-key-treating-autism-Researchers-say-children-pets-far-better-social-skills.html
Researchers at the Research Center for Human Interaction at the College of Veterinary Medicine at the University of Missouri have found that autistic children with better have better social skills than those that don't have them (Prigg, 2015, January 2, para. 2). Moreover, “When pets are present in the classroom, children talk and engage more with each other (Prigg, 2015, January 2, para 8). If this is true, wouldn't Asperger's and High Functioning Autism children benefit from regular classroom and library visits of therapy dogs?
Laube, Gloria. (2014, December 16). A dog in the library. Library Dogs. Retrieved from http://www.librarydogs.com/
Therapy Dogs International. 2015). Retrieved from http://www.tdi-dog.org/OurPrograms.aspx?Page=Libraries
Addendum
January 3, 2015
Researchers at the Research Center for Human Interaction at the College of Veterinary Medicine at the University of Missouri have found that autistic children with better have better social skills than those that don't have them (Prigg, 2015, January 2, para. 2). Moreover, “When pets are present in the classroom, children talk and engage more with each other (Prigg, 2015, January 2, para 8). If this is true, wouldn't Asperger's and High Functioning Autism children benefit from regular classroom and library visits of therapy dogs?
Laube, Gloria. (2014, December 16). A dog in the library. Library Dogs. Retrieved from http://www.librarydogs.com/
Therapy Dogs International. 2015). Retrieved from http://www.tdi-dog.org/OurPrograms.aspx?Page=Libraries
------------
Grandin, Temple. (2001,
December). Genius may be an abnormality: Educating students with
Asperger's Syndrome or High Functioning Autism. Indiana Resource
Center for Autism. Retrieved from
http://www.iidc.indiana.edu/index.php?pageId=598
Temple Grandlin, who has
succeeded despite her Asperger's Syndrome diagnosis, argues that only
intellectually satisfying work makes life meaningful” for
individuals with Asperger's or HFA (2001, December, para. 2-4).
Continuum of Traits
A continuum of personality
and intellectual traits ranging from normal to abnormal separate
those individuals with AS or HFA behaviors from the general
population (Grandlin, 2001, December, para. 5). AS and HFA have a
strong genetic basis since researchers have discovered that
two-thirds of all families with a HFA child have either a first or
second degree relative who has exhibited AS behaviors (Grandlin,
2001, December, para. 7).
Genius is an Abnormality
Children and adults who
excel in one subject, like math, often have problems learning other
subjects (Grandlin, 2001, December para. 9). Medical studies have
also linked manic depression with creativity while the mathematical
gifted are also often near-sightedness and have an increased
susceptibility to allergies (Grandlin, 2001, December, para. 10).
Many engineers and computer programmers also display a high incidence
of AS or HFA traits (Grandlin, 2001, December, para. 11).
A Web page from the United
Kingdom also cautions readers that Asperger's diagnosed individuals
who make it to college must still cope with learning disabilities
caused by this genetically-inherited condition.
Guidelines for teaching
students with Asperger Syndrome in further education colleges. (n.
d.). National Autistic Society [United Kingdom].
The National Autistic
Society cautions that Asperger's and High Functioning Autism problems
continue into adulthood:
Staff need to understand
that a “triad of [autistic] impairments”--social communication
difficulties, social interaction problems, and failure to use social
imagination—as well as AS specific traits can influence AS young
adults' behavior (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 1-4).
Characteristics Specific
to Aserger Syndrome
AS college and university students may [still] exhibit language peculiarities, self-impose rigid rules and routines, have problems reading non-verbal cues, be clumsy, have problems making friends, and obsess over overwhelming interests (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 5).
Autistic spectrum
disorders evidence rigid thinking and the inability to cope with
change, so young adults with AS function better in highly-structured
situations (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 6), so even a
little change in a routine can cause stress, upsetting them. Thus,
instructors need to remember that change needs to be gradual, thus
keeping variations in a class routine to a minimum (National Autistic
Society, n. d., para. 7—8).
Everyday Considerations: Teacher as Positive
Role-Model
Teachers dictate their class's style of communication, indicating accepted levels of behavior as well as the students' responses and attitudes, so if an instructor's sarcasm or ridicule indicates that poking fun at someone is okay, it becomes “open season”. Conversely, a professor's patient and understanding behavior can set the classroom norm (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 10-12).
Who should be told about
the [AS or HFA] diagnosis?
This very personal decision should be left up to individual students to make after careful thought (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 13).
What problems may occur within the teaching setting?
Group Work
AS students may find group work stressful, for they have problems empathizing with others. Certain members of the group or a staff member may therefore need to step in and act as mediators to ensure that the AS student understands what others in a group expect of him or her (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 14).
Lack of Comprehension
Figurative language may confuse AS students, who simultaneously feel embarrassed and reluctant to admit that they don't understand a remark. AS individuals often use coping mechanisms, like humor, to cover up this problem. The instructor [or another student acting as a mentor] at this point can step in to interpret what another person has said (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 15).
Lack of Empathy
Educational psychologists refer to the AS individuals' inability to show empathy as a lack of “Theory of Mind” (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 16). When they show a disregard for others' feelings, an instructor or colleague therefore needs to quietly and sincerely tell them what effect their words or actions have had, or else they might not make this connection on their own (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 16). Also, because AS individuals have trouble interpreting nonverbal parts of a conversation as well as understanding the facial expressions that often accompany sarcasm, the difference between what they know and what they think their audience knows may also result in bruised feelings and misunderstandings (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 17—18).
Problem with Motivation
Most students apply themselves to learning a course's entire curriculum, including parts of it they don't like, but AS students may focus only on what they enjoy doing, sabotaging their own changes of success (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 10).
Distress Caused by Lack of Information
Detailed information reassures autism spectrum individuals (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 20).
Social Chameleons
AS individuals are good at blending in when they participate in familiar situations with predictable events; but when things go wrong, they reveal themselves as individuals coping with High-Functioning Autism (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 21).
A Final Caveat
No two individuals with Asperger's or Autism act in the same manner (National Autistic Society, n. d., para. 22).
See also:
Roome, Deborah. (2011). Asperger's occupations: Embarking on a successful career. Healthguideinfo.com. Retrieved from http://www.healthguideinfo.com/aspergers-syndrome/p110668/
Careers that are Asperger's
friendly—like engineering, computer programming, accounting, and
library cataloging--tend to concentrate on lots of details.
Hutten, Mark. (2013, February). 70
tips and tricks for educating students with Aspergers/High
Functioning Autism. My Aspergers Child. Retrieved from
http://www.myaspergerschild.com/2013/02/70-tips-tricks-for-educating-students.html
Psychologist and family therapist
Mark Hatten identifies classroom characteristics that promote
academic success in Asperger's and High Functioning Autism students:
Individualized instruction, interesting lessons, positive
reinforcement, predictability, short working periods, small
teacher-student ratios, and lots of structure (2013, February, para.
1). Ideally, the teacher should be consistently firm, possess a sense
of humor, understand and apply a host of behavior management
strategies workable with autistic spectrum students, and be patience
and warn while showing high academic expectations as he or she
continuously monitors AS students' work (Hatten, 2013, February,
para. 2). That's not to say that these quick tips won't work with
other students as well.
Language comprehension/auditory
processing difficulties. (n. d.). Special Ed.US.
Retrieved from http://www.specialed.us/autism/asper/asper12.html
Asperger's Syndrome individuals interpret auditory information literally and concretely, for they have trouble understanding figurative languages. Additionally, AS learners may need more wait time than other students to respond to questions before responding (Special Ed, n. d., para. 1).
Retrieved from http://www.specialed.us/autism/asper/asper12.html
Asperger's Syndrome individuals interpret auditory information literally and concretely, for they have trouble understanding figurative languages. Additionally, AS learners may need more wait time than other students to respond to questions before responding (Special Ed, n. d., para. 1).
Language
Comprehension/Auditory Processing—Intervention Strategies
- Keep auditory prompting to a minimum,, providing visual cues;
- Give AS listeners enough time to respond to questions.
- Provide written [and perhaps illustrated rules], so AS students can comply with with rules and turn in assignments;
- Write auditory instructions on a dry erase board;
- Provide concrete explanations as necessary, explaining figurative language and idioms by furnishing visual cues.(Special Ed., n. d., para. 2)
Sensory Process
Difficulties
Hypersensitive (over responses) and
hypo-sensitive (under responses) to sensory stimuli limit AS
individuals' ability to focus their attention over longer time spans
(Special Ed., n. d., para. 3).
Sensory
Processing—Intervention Strategies
- Allow AS students to wear head phones as necessary to block out distracting noise;
- Permit AS students to use headphones to listen to calming instrumental music [without words];
- Warn AS students ahead of time of any impending fire and tornado drills.
- Put in place a “daily sensory diet” of calming and kinesthetic activities:
- Deep pressure (pressure touch) activities: firm hugs, massage;
- Rhythmic vestibular stimulation: swinging, rocking in a rocking chair, bicycling, jumping, bouncing;
- Proprioceptive stimulation: sitting on a t-stool or therapy ball to increase focus and attention.
(Special
Ed., n. d., para. 4 & 5)
See also:
Chiappi, Jacqueline. (2012, January
17). Take advantage of the theory of multiple intelligences. Bright
Hub Education. Retrieved from
http://www.brighthubeducation.com/teaching-elementary-school/5836-use-multiple-intelligences-activities-in-your-classroom/
Gris, Susan. (2013, March 20). The
power of movement in teaching and learning. Education Week
Teacher. Retrieved from
http://www.edweek.org/tm/articles/2013/03/19/fp_griss.html
Wile, Elise. (2014). Kinesthetic
learning games. Demand Media. Retrieved from
http://www.ehow.com/info_8185695_kinesthetic-learning-games.htm
Although elementary education
teachers take advantage of kinesthetic learning games and vary
teaching activities to appeal to students with different learning
strengths, secondary teachers can take advantage of these theories as
well, breaking the class into segments by their use.
Difficulty
Representing Language Internally
AS listeners often “blurt out”
thoughts as factual information, thus appearing to be lacking in tact
(Special Ed., n. d., para. 6).
Representing
Language Internally—Intervention Strategies
- If necessary, encourage AS students to whisper their thoughts, but encourage a “think it, don't say it” strategy;
- Role play, use audio/visual taping, and social scripting to teach Asperger's children and teenagers how to identify which thoughts are best unspoken.(Special Ed., n. d., para. 7)
Insistence on
Sameness
AS individuals become quite anxious
when facing the unknown and unpredictable.
Characteristics:
Consider the following personality traits of Asperger's individuals:
Consider the following personality traits of Asperger's individuals:
- AS individuals rely on rigid egocentric perceptions to give order to their existence;
- AS individuals habitually adhere to internalized rules based on previous experiences;
- They need to experience closure when finishing a particular activity before moving on to a new one.(Special Ed., n. d., para. 8)
Insistence on
Sameness—Intervention Strategies
- Maintain a predictable classroom or home environment with minimal transitions;
- Use a visual schedule alerting AS children and teenagers about changes in their routines;
- Modify assignments to ensure that AS students compete them with the assigned period of time;
- Have AS student submit unfinished work to a “finish later” box or folder.
(Special
Ed., n. d., para. 9)
Poor
Concentration/Distractability/Disorganization
Characteristics: AS students
often go off task, distracted by internal thoughts and external
stimuli. Thus they have difficulty,
- Organizing their thoughts cohesively;
- Gathering together the materials necessary to complete tasks;
- Keeping track of their belongings;
- Organizing a desk, locker, closet, or room.(Special Ed., n. d., para. 10)
Concentration/Distractability/Disorganization—Intervention
Strategies
- Provide AS learners with a very structured education environment;
- Use a timer to help learners with time management skills;
- Furnish a written checklist to keep AS students on task;
- Provide AS students a visual schedule or syllabus for each class;
- Post a visual calendar at home and in the AS students' lockers or desks at school;
- Give AS students written cues, using handouts or a dry erase board;
- Match subject notebooks with their companion textbooks by wrapping textbooks in the same colored book covers;
- Issue [and regularly review] an assignment notebook;
- On tests and worksheets, place fewer questions per page, using visual spaces to separate different questions.
- Have a go-to “assignments to be completed” as well as “completed assignments” folders for AS students.
(Special
Ed., n. d., para. 11)
Emotional
Vulnerability
Characteristics: Seeking
perfection, AS learners often suffer from low self-esteem, are super
self-critical, often are easily overwhelmed, stressed out and
frustrated (Special Ed., n. d., para. 12).
Emotional
Vulnerability—Intervention Strategies
- Capitalize on Asperger's students' strengths, assigning special projects where they can excel.
- Teach AS students relaxation techniques to decrease their anxiety.*
(Special Ed.,
n. d., para. 12)
*See also:
Moninger,
Jeanette. (2014). 10 relaxation techniques that zap stress fast. Web
M.D. Retrieved from
http://www.webmd.com/balance/guide/blissing-out-10-relaxation-techniques-reduce-stress-spot
Oak, Manali.
(2012, March 12). Top ten relaxation techniques for children.
Buzzle. Retrieved from
http://www.buzzle.com/articles/top-ten-relaxation-techniques-for-children.html
Relaxing yoga
poses for beginners. (2014). Education. Yoga Outlet.
Retrieved from
http://www.yogaoutlet.com/guides/relaxing-yoga-poses-for-beginners
Restricted
Range of Interests
- AS individuals often display eccentric preoccupations and/or fixations:
- In conversation, AS individuals may lecture others on specific obscure topics;
- Overly anxious, they may have trouble letting go of obsessions;
- AS students may refuse to learn anything other than their favorite topics or interests.
(Special
Ed., n. d., para. 13)
Restrictive
Range of Interest—Intervention Strategies
- Outside of class, set aside specific times to discuss AS students' interests with them;
- Provide written answers to repetitive questions;
- Fit AS learners' interests into an individualized curriculum.
(Special
Ed., n. d., para. 14)
Difficulty Taking
the Perspective of Others
- AS individuals have trouble understanding that others' thoughts, desires, and beliefs differ from their own:
- During a lecture or lesson, AS learners think the teacher is speaking directly to them, thus calling out an answer or comments.
- AS students are extremely vulnerable when other students urge them to do or say things that will get them in trouble.
- AS individuals unintentionally often display a lack of empathy.
- They may have trouble understanding how and why they misbehave and how what they say can affect how others think and feel.(Special Ed., n. d., para. 15)
Cooperative Learning
Groups Cause Problems for AS Learners
- An AS mindset often causes confusion or resentment in other group members:
- AS individuals don't necessarily know what their listeners already know;
- AS speakers may give not enough [or too much] informational background;
- They may also exclude relational information, or else they might relay too much detail.
- AS individuals also may lack the ability to deceive, and they may not even understand duplicity.
(Special
Ed., n. d., para. 16)
Mind Reading/Theory
of Mind Deficit—Intervention Strategies
- Read Teaching Children with Autism to Mind Read : A Practical Resource:
Howlin,
Patricia, Baron-Cohen, Simon, and Hadwin, Julie A. (1998). Teaching
Children with Autism to Mind Read: A Practical Guide for Teachers
and Parents. Chichester, England: John A. Wiley.
- Teach AS children [and teenagers] to recognize the effect of what they say and how they act;
- Use comic strips and simple line drawing to clarify social interactions;
- Turn to popular literature, videos, movies, and TV shows to help AS individuals to interpret the actions of others.
(Special
Ed., n. d., para. 17)
Conclusion: AS
students can be successfully mainstreamed into a traditional
classroom setting if equipped with appropriate learning strategies,
receiving specific instruction on how to behave, and learning through
direct instruction and necessary accommodations to fit their learning
styles, (Special Ed., n. d., para. 18). However, this takes a lot of
parental effort outside the classroom!
May, Kelly. (2005,
September). Teaching strategies for Asperger students. New
Horizons for Learning. Johns Hopkins School of Education.
Retrieved from
http://education.jhu.edu/PD/newhorizons/Exceptional%20Learners/Autism/Articles/Teaching%20Strategies%20for%20Asperger%20Students/
Since the Individuals
with Disabilities Act guarantees that learning-disabled students be
placed in the least restrictive environment possible, Asperger's
Syndrome and High-Functioning Autism students have become a challenge
for all classroom teachers (May, 2005, September, para. 1-4),since
they have to use a variety of strategies to connect with all their
students. Most classroom teachers without Special Education training,
therefore, feel hampered both by a lack of expertise as well as not
having special education experts on hand (May, 2005, September, para.
5).
Review of Related
Literature
Although AS students more
readily acquire language and develop cognitive skills than other
autism- labeled individuals, their behavior is similar since they
often are unable to get along with their peers because they have
trouble interpreting non-verbal facial cues; they display
inflexibility when changes occur in their routines, and they often
show obsessive preoccupations with their favorite topics of
conversation (May, 2005, September, para. 6).
___________
Theories Associated
with AS
Behaviorist Theory
explains that “mal-adaptive behavior” in AS individuals results
from 1) “a failure to learn necessary adaptive behaviors or
competencies,” and from 2) learned “ineffective or mal-adaptive
processes” (May, 2005, September, para. 8).
AS individuals often
don''t detect social cues, and most AS individuals don't know how to
read facial expressions. Thus, they repeat irritating behavior (May,
2005, September, para. 9).
Parents and teachers can
apply positive reinforcements when dealing with AS students if
they reinforce positive behavior with an activity an AS student would
like to do (May, 2005, September, para. 10).
Applied Behavior
Analysis and Discrete Trial Learning (ABA/DTL) also works
well with AS students since these strategies break down learning into
small steps that build on each other (May, 2005, September, para.
12). Applying ABA and DTL lets AS students focus on small bits of
information without feeling overwhelmed (May, 2005, September, para.
12).
Teaching Strategies
for Curriculum Education
Because average to above
average IQ scores mask AS characteristics, teachers often
misunderstand AS behaviors. AS students may also become over
stimulated when participating in small group work or team projects
(May, 2005, September, para. 13).
An Academic Physical
and Interpersonal (API) Inclusion Plan should address the
AS student's academic, physical, and interpersonal challenges (May,
2005, September, para. 14). Unfortunately, however, if one was to
design an environment “geared to stress a person with AS, you would
probably come up with something that looked like a school” (May,
2005, September, para. 15). Accordingly, teachers need to take into
account all the noise, nonrestrictive time periods, and distractions
that torment AS students (May, 2005, September, para. 16). For
example, everyday sounds sometime produce the same reaction in AS
students as nails scrapping across a chalkboard. Therefore, AS
students may need to listen to soft music [without lyrics] with
headsets or use earplugs to block out excessive, unwanted noise (May,
2005, September, para. 17).
Minimizing transitions
and making the environment predicable alleviates stress for AS
students as does warning them when there will be changes in their
daily routines (May, 2005, September, para. 18). Because AS students
beginning in the upper elementary grades often need to change
classes, a transition planning meeting at the beginning of the
semester will help both AS students and their teachers prevent
unnecessary traumas (May, 2005, September, para. 19). A one-on-one
teacher's aide can also shadow individual AS students, keeping them
on task (May, 2005, September, para. 20).
___________
Strategies for Social
Education
Group projects cause
problems for AS students because they involve social interaction
(May, 2005, September, para. 20). The AS students “Hidden
Curriculum” therefore must include the “basic how-to's of living”
that other kids seem to know. AS students can be empowered by
addressing “Scope and Sequence” issues, proving direct
instruction through the reading of social stories, acting lessons
[role-playing social situations], and self-esteem building (May,
2005, September, para. 21).
For instance, since
changing classes stresses out AS students, they should be allowed to
leave class five minutes before the bell rings (May, 2005, September,
para.22).
Since AS students are
often unable to generalize concepts, such as how to respectfully
address an authority figure, they might not be able to apply already
learned social skills to a new situation. In other words, just
because an AS student might know how to talk to his or her teacher,
he or she might not have transferred this skill and show the proper
deference to a police officer without participating in Scope and
Sequence rehearsals (May, 2005, September, para. 23). Similarly,
teachers give instructions to a class might need to break them down
into steps since AS students might not be able to infer all the
desired behavior (May, 2005, September, para. 25).
A Unified Plan of Support
(UPI) team of teachers meeting monthly can exchange ideas about how
best to deal with AS and other learning disabled students (May,
2005, September, para. 26).
In conclusion, since the
IDEA Act mandates that learning disabled students be placed in the
least restrictive environment possible, this can only be achieved
successfully if teachers constantly re-evaluate their teaching
strategies (May, 2005, September, para. 27).
Safran, Joan S. (2001). Supporting
students with Asperger's Syndrome in General Education. Council for
Exceptional Children, 35(5), pp.60-66. Retrieved from
http://sacramentoasis.com/docs/7-13-07/supporting_students_with_as.pdf
Asperger's is “a
neurologically-based, autism spectrum disorder” that “significantly
affects social perception, interactions, language and non verbal
communication”, so those children and adults displaying the
behavioral traits of Asperger's, or High-Functioning Autism, despite
their average to superior intelligence, haven't intuited the social
awareness needed to connect successfully with their peers (Safran,
2001, p. 60).
Ordinarily, these individuals don't
experience any delays in language development or lack cognitive
ability; however, their speech may be overly formal, monotone, or way
too loud (Safran, 2001, p. 61). While most school districts
mainstream these students, some school systems furnish full-time
aides to act as mentors,but others attempt to function without any
formal support (Safran, 2001, p. 61). While their academic
performance ranges from adequate to exceptional, without adequate
planning, they ordinarily don't do well in cooperative learning or
group work situations (Safran, 2001, p. 61).
What Teachers Need
to Know
School personnel [including
substitute teachers] need to familiarize themselves with the
behavioral characteristics of AS even if not all AS students exhibit
every AS characteristic (Safran, 2001, p. 61). All too often, AS
students' intelligence and vocabulary mask this disability, or else,
their behavioral problems might lead to a misdiagnoses of
Attention-Deficit Disorder (Safran, 2001, p. 61). Since most
of these students don't have obvious physical disabilities, their
absence leaves peers and adults without an explanation for their
clumsy social interactions (Safran, 2001, p. 61).
See also:
Aspergers vs ADHD. (2006). ADHD
News. Retrieved from
http://www.adhdnews.com/testforum/test8218.htm
Autism’s commonalities with ADHD.
ASD-Autism Spectrum Disorders. (1999, September 11). Retrieved from
http://www.retrainthebrain.com/autism.html
Obviously, both ADHD and AS students
can benefit from some of the same study helps and behavioral
modification techniques as can their classmates.
Special Education teachers,
counselors, and therapists need to directly teach social skills to AS
students, but inclusion teachers also need to know how to be a part
of this support team (Safran, 2001, p. 62).
Carefully Structure
Seating Arrangements and Group Worksheets
Take care not to seat AS students
next to bullies, but instead assign them seats next to peer buddies,
who can take them aside and carefully explain certain social niceties
or answer questions about the lesson. AS students also function well
when seated near the teacher at the front of the classroom or in an
open quiet area (Safran, 2001, p.62). Teachers of AS students should
avoid self-selection in group work and ensure that all group members
function as a team. Because AS students might not pick up on other
students' reactions, non-verbal cues (like the teacher's pulling on
his or her ear) will remind them that they need to budget their
speaking time can keep them from embarrassing themselves (Safran,
2001, p. 62).
Provide a Safe Haven
AS students often stress out when
confronted with loud assemblies, pep rallies, and unstructured recess
time, so ear plugs and head phones can be used to block irritating
noises while retreating to a quiet place like the school library at
this time might be an alternative to attending these events (Safran,
2001, p. 63). Teachers also need to learn how to detect behaviors
like pacing or singing to oneself that indicate an AS student's
“approaching meltdown” (Safran, 2001, p. 63).
In social situations, AS individuals
might see themselves as “on stage” or “on alert” when
speaking in class, thus substituting intellectual analysis [or
comically behavior] for natural empathy and insight (Safran, 2001, p.
63). Since AS individuals don't automatically internalize social
rules, observers might find them “irritating, rude, and immature”
(Safran, 2001, p. 54). They also might misunderstand metaphorical
comments, friendly teasing, and sarcasm (Safran, 2001, p. 64), so
teachers and peers need to be on alert to serve as “social
translators” (Safran, 2001, p. 64).
Fixation on a particular topic in
conversation and an unwillingness to save comments or questions for
later during an instructor's lecture also characterize AS
individuals, so posted class rules might never to include reminders
like “Only five minutes is allowed for questions” (Safran, 2001,
p. 64).
Prepare for Changes
in Routine
Posting class schedules and time
frames and clearly delineating classroom spaces for particular
activities also reduces AS students' anxiety levels while they also
find “to do” lists and assignment books “indispensable”
Accordingly, AS students need to receive notices of changes in their
routine in advance (Safran, 2001, p. 64).
Use Available
Resources/Make Needed Accommodations
AS individuals respond well to
visuals, graphics, modeling, and the use of technology. Since they
often have impaired gross and find motor skills, they may need to use
a personal computer for completing written assignments and exams
(Safran, 2001, p. 64). Access to the Web also offers them “the
communication they desire . . . [without] “the overwhelming sensory
overload” (Safran, 2001, p. 65). Even so, limit the time AS
students spend on the Web, so this doesn't turn into
obsessive-compulsive behavior or a substitute for human contact
(Safran, 2001, p. 65).
Contact with Significant Others
Regular meetings, phone calls, and
e-mails from inclusion and special education teachers and counselors
can provide the support that keeps parents of AS students from
feeling isolated (Safran, 2001, p. 65). However, teachers also need
to come up with creative ways to help AS students to connect with
kind and empathetic peers as well as providing direct instruction in
conversation skills. Here the instructor can use comic strip
conversations and social story strategies to teach turn taking
(Safran, 2001, p. 65).
Additionally, counselors can direct
AS students towards participating in well-structured activities and
clubs while steering them away from unstructured events (Safran,
2001, p. 65). Teachers and counselors might also create a
peer-buddy system, pairing AS students with peers who might offer
friendship and social interaction while respecting difference
(Safran, 2001, p. 65).
Help Your Classroom
Become a Caring Community
Safran also urges educators to
maintain a classroom that is a “safe, supportive, and accepting
community for everyone”, embracing diversity, for isolation brings
about depression and suicide while a sense of belonging serves as a
deterrent to self-destructive behavior (2001, p. 65). People with
Asperger's have great creative potential, but as they age, depression
interferes with their functioning (Safran, 2001, p. 66).
Webster, Jerry. (2014). Asperger's
Syndrome in the general education classroom. About Education.
About.com. Retrieved from
http://specialed.about.com/od/autismandaspergers/a/Aspergers-Syndrome-In-The-General-Education-Classroom.htm
Teachers ordinary experience the
following problems when working with Asperger Syndrome students:
- AS children display unusual sensory needs.
- They hyper-focus on their preferred subjects
- They tend to have poor executive function skills.
- They may break down emotionally when they become frustrated.
(Webster, 2014,
para. 1)
Sensory Needs
Students who display some of the
symptoms of Asperger Disorder might display a hypersensitivity to
certain sensory stimuli, so paying attention to how they might react
to distractions like loud noises, rough surfaces, or cold or heat can
help manage their responses. Conversely, some sensory inputs like
chewing gum or sitting on a Pilates ball can be calming if they don't
over stimulate an AS student (Webster, 2014, para. 2-5).
Hypo-focus on a Preferred Subject
When AS students focus intensely on
a single interest, use their intensity to serve as a scaffold,
linking their passion to other topics. Also let them really excel in
their area of expertise (Webster, 2014, para. 6-8).
Poor Executive Function
AS students often have trouble
keeping up with their possessions and remembering the routine tasks
they need to perform, so they can benefit from simple graphic
organizers and work charts (Webster, 2014, para. 9-10).
Low Frustration Level
Because AS students often experience
low frustration levels when confronted with what for them is a
challenging task, a teacher should have some contingency plans on
hand to calm them:
- Allow them to take a short, five-minute break;
- Send them on an errand if a melt-down is in progress.
The teacher might also tailor their
assignments and tests by limiting the number of items per page as
well as assigning shorter homework assignments than they assign to
most of the class (Webster, 2014, para. 11-13).
Stay Flexible
Since AS students often have
difficult accepting change, their teachers have to stay flexible when
working with them (Webster, 2014, para. 14).
Since few students master the
appropriate balance between specificity and the ability to summarize
a passage's main idea, all students can benefit from using some of
the learning techniques that might help Asperger's students. After
all, everyone profits from thinking about thinking.
____________
Here's a new, free Online resource for
kids: http://www.dkfindout.com/us/ (2015, January 29).
To register, the user needs to confirm
that he or she is over 18 and give his or her age to have access to
verifiable information on animals and nature, dinosaurs and
prehistoric life, the Earth, English, history, the human body, math,
science, and space. The dkfindout Website might serve as as
an alternative resource to use instead of Wikipedia (a source
that most teachers won't accept because it lacks true editorial
oversight, although the user can certainly click on hyperlinks for
documented sources).
No comments:
Post a Comment