Sunday, March 9, 2014

A Review of Simone Elkeles' Young Adult Romances


Another Side of Chicago: 
Simone Elkeles’ Young Adult Novels


(Photo courtesy Orbitz)


Evelyn Smith

MS in Library Science, University of North Texas (2012)

Ph. D. in English, Texas Christian University (1995)


While Veronica Roth's Divergent trilogy features a female protagonist who lives in a Dystopian Chicago sometime in the future, Simone Elkeles’ Young Adult romances pair upscale, present-day, Chicago-area, White Anglo-Saxon Protestant or Jewish female leads with Israeli, bad-boy, or Hispanic boyfriends while along the way almost all the major teenage characters have to work through common adolescent problems--divorced or never married parents, new schools, and the angst of trying to fit in but not always being part of the in crowd.

Since I was lucky enough to win a complete run of autographed Simone Elkeles’ Young Adult romance novels at the Texas Library Association Convention in April 2013, in retrospect, I'm pleased to announce that last summer I donated them to the West High School Library.  As readers may recall, an explosion of an ammonium nitrate plant in West, Texas, on April 17, 2013, killed 15 residents and destroyed or damaged 150 buildings, including the town's middle and high school.  Although Elkeles’ novels might seem like an unusual choice to give to a rural, Texas high school, Texas teens, like everyone else, compare their lives with other young adults elsewhere.  Indeed, these novels might serve as a guide to what wealthy Chicago-area teenage girls are wearing.
 
In October 2013, Macmillan published Elkeles’ latest romance, Wild Cards, a formulaic-story that follows her usual feisty female protagonist as she falls in love with a stereotypical bad boy:  This time, Elkeles pairs Ashtyn, the tom-boy captain of a suburban Chicago-area high school football team, with Derek, a quarterback who is struggling to come to terms with an absentee military dad and a new step-mother he despises. While Elkeles’ novels interest high school readers, they often have lower reading levels; for example, Rules for Attraction has a 5.2 reading level.  She also hypes her audience's interest by releasing videos dramatizing or publicizing her novels on YouTube.

The How to Ruin series, however, is perhaps Elkeles’ best series because she is more at home here.  Elkeles’ first-person narrative tells about a world that she knows, the life of an American Jewish Princess with a most probably “unchurched” WASP, vaguely-feminist, advertising executive mother, who can afford to gift her Jimmy Choo shoes, even if Elkeles indulges in a bit of over-the-top fantasy: Amy Nelson-Barak’s dad is also a former Israeli Commando turned security consultant.   One of the videos Elkeles has put on YouTube discloses her strong ties to a local Jewish synagogue.

The How to Ruin series sees Amy grow from a self-absorbed teenager preoccupied with the latest designer clothes to a more mature and focused young woman.  This transformation begins to occur after she falls in love with an Israeli soldier while simultaneously discovering her Israeli roots one summer on the kibbutz where her dad's family lives. Subsequent novels follow Amy as she moves in with her dad back home in Chicago after her mother marries. In the third novel, Amy volunteers to serve as a ten-day volunteer trainee for the Israeli Defense Force, so she can be nearer her boyfriend.  Along the way, Amy investigates Judaism and joins a Jewish youth group that accompanies her back to Israel, although I suspect that Elkeles wrote the novel after seeing Private Benjamin.

The third novel in this first-person trilogy might be a little too risqué for middle school students since Amy and Ari, the Israeli soldier she falls in love with, spend a night together.  Even so, the trilogy--as well as each separate book in it--tells a classic Coming of Age tale as Amy starts to care more about others than herself. The series also underlines the idea that American Jews like other early 20th-century immigrant groups while proud of their ancestry are thoroughly assimilated.

Elkeles has grouped her work into the following collections, which readers might wish to read in sequence:

How to Ruin Trilogy:


  •   How to Ruin a Summer Vacation (2006)
  • How to Ruin My Teenage Life (2007)
  • How to Ruin Your Boyfriend's Reputation (2009)


Leaving Paradise/Return to Paradise Series:


  • Leaving Paradise (2007)
  •  Return to Paradise (2010)

Perfect Chemistry Trilogy:


  • Perfect Chemistry (2008)
  •  Rules of Attraction (2010)
  • Chain Reaction (2011)


Wild Cards Series:


  •      Wild Cards (2013)


Awards and Recognition


Additionally, Elkeles has received the following awards and recognition:

  • Author of the Year by the Illinois Association of Teachers of English  (2008)
  • Illinois “Read for Lifetime” Booklist for Chain Reaction (2012-2013)
  • New York Times Best Seller List for Rules of Attraction and Return to Paradise
  • RITA  Award for Best Young Adult Romance for Perfect Chemistry (2010)
  • USA Today Best Sellers List
  • Young Adult Library Service Association (YALSA) Top Ten Quick Picks for Reluctant Readers List for Chain Reaction (2012)
  • YALSA Popular Paperbacks List for Perfect Chemistry (2012)


Selected Simone Elkeles' Videos

Elkeles markets her books with official and semiofficial videos while fans have also prepared their own video tributes:

Author: Simone Elkeles on Tape with Rabbi Doug.  (2008, Dec. 7).  YouTube.

Chain Reaction book trailer by Simone Elkeles OFFICIAL.  (2011, July 20).  YouTube.

How to Ruin a Summer Vacation.  (2006, August 16).  YouTube.  Retrieved from

How to Ruin Your Boyfriend’s Reputation by Simone Elkeles Book Trailer.  (2010,
January 30).  YouTube.  Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oi57r57aY9Y

Interview with Simone Elkeles—YouTube. (2011, April 26).  YouTube.  Retrieved from

“Lightning Round” with Simone Elkeles.  (2011, May 6).  YouTube.  Retrieved from

Rules of Attraction by Simone Elkeles Official Book Trailer.   (2010, March 8). YouTube

Simone Elkeles—Perfect Chemistry Rap Video Book Trailer.  (2008, December 8).  .

YA Author Simone Elkeles and her ‘hero’ is interviewed.   (2010, August 4). RT
BookreviewYou Tube.  Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q2GSeyHOoRA

Wild Cards Ep. 1 based on the Wild Cards novels by Simone Elkeles. (2013, September 13).  Enomis Entertainment.  YouTube. Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bfSfG5AECY

Wild Cards Ep. 2 based on the Wild Cards novels by Simone Elkeles. (2013, September 17).  YouTube. Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oks51v6kXwk

Wild Cards Ep. 3 based on the Wild Card novels by Simon Elkeles (2013, September 21). YouTube. Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tFrC8SSq7k4

Wild Cards Ep. 4 FINALE based on the Wild Card novels by Simon Elkeles. (2013, September 30).  YouTube. Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kTprmMExA6A


Simone Elkeles 
Annotated 
Bibliography

Bush, Elizabeth. (2006, December).  How to Ruin a Summer Vacation (review).  Bulletin
of the Center for Children Books, 60 (4), p. 167.  doi: 10.1353/bcc/2006.0000. Project Muse. Retrieved from http://muse.jhu.edu/login?auth=0&type=summary&url=/journals/bulletin_of_the_center_for_childrens_books/v060/60.4bush01.html

Bush finds the character overdrawn, but she feels that the tale shows how the heroine’s vacation in Israel helps her bond both with her dad and her Jewish heritage
.
Coats, Karen.  (2009, May).  Perfect Chemistry (review).  Bulletin of the Center for
Children’s Books, 62(9), p. 36. doi: 10.1242/bcc/0098. Project Muse.  Retrieved from

Coat notes that the stereotyped protagonists, the suburbanite cheerleader and Hispanic gang leader/chemistry partner are both the strengths and the weaknesses of this novel.

Creel, Stacy. (2013). Talk dirty to me: Why books about sex and relationships belong in
libraries. SLIS Connecting, 2(1), Article 5.  Retrieved from

Creel cites Elkeles’ Return to Paradise and Rules for Attraction as appropriate novels for teaching young adults about sexual relationships.

Cummins, Jane. (2011, Fall).  What are Jewish boys and girls made of? Gender in
contemporary Jewish teen and tween fiction.  Contemporary Children’s Literature Association Quarterly, 36(3), 296-319. doi: 10.1356/chq/2011.0033.  Project Muse.  Abstract retrieved from http://muse.jhu.edu/login?auth=0&type=summary&url=/journals/childrens_literature_association_quarterly/v036/36.3.cummins.html

Cummins singles out Elkeles as just one of the relatively recent YA authors who “glibly deals with Jewish identity issues” faced by a Jewish protagonist in a contemporary setting instead of focusing on early 20th-century immigrants or the Holocaust.

Ivey, Gail & Johnston, Peter H. (2013, March 20).  Engagement with young adult
literature: Outcomes and processes.  Reading Research Quarterly.  doi:
10.1002/rrq.46.  Wiley Online Library.  Retrieved from http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/rrq.46/abstract

Ivey and Johnston examine students’ perceptions of self-selected, self-paced reading in a classroom setting, including a reader’s review of Perfect Chemistry.

Read for a lifetime booklist. (2012-2013).  Cyberdrive. Retrieved from

Read for a Lifetime includes Elkeles’ Chain Reaction with Frank McCourt’s Angela’s Ashes, John Green’s The Fault in Our Stars, and Ransom Riggs’ Miss Peregrine’s Homes for Peculiar Children as one of 25 notable Young Adult books.  

Rock, Jeana Terry, McCollum, Amanda J., & Hesser, Gregory.  Professional
Resources.  Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 53(1), 87-92.  doi: 10.1598/JAAL.53.1.10.  Retrieved from http://www.englishcompanion.com/pdfDocs/JAAL_Reviews_EC_Ning.pdf

The authors mention that Elkeles “Perfect Chemistry Rap” is available for both teacher information and entertainment purposes (p. 89).

*Rules for Attraction. (2013). Book Wizard. Scholastic. Retrieved from

*Simone Elkeles. (2013). Goodreads.  Retrieved from

*Simone Elkeles. (2013). Linkedin.  Retrieved from

*Simone Elkeles. (n. d.).  Retrieved from http://simoneelkeles.com/about/

*Simone Elkeles. (2014, January 14).  Wikipedia.  Retrieved from

*Simone Elkeles. (2013). Zoominfo.com.  Retrieved from

*Wild Card (Wild Crds#1) by Simone Elkeles.  (2013, October 1). Goodreads. Retrieved  from https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13065327-wild-cards

*These sources understandably aren't annotated, but they may prove helpful to YA readers.

------


2014 Lists for Best
Young Adult Fiction


Chilton, Martin. The 36 best young adult books of 2014. The Telegraph. Retrieved from http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/books/bookreviews/11030589/The-best-young-adult-books-of-2014.html

For a British take on the most outstanding Young Adult novels for 2014 access this link from The Telegraph.

2014 best fiction for young adults.  (2014).  Young Adult Library Services Association (YALSA). American Library Assocation. Retrieved from http://www.ala.org/yalsa/2014-best-fiction-young-adults

The following selections make YALSA's best young adult books list for 2014. 

No comments:

Post a Comment